The FBI is contacting Wisconsin election officials. Here鈥檚 what we know.
The FBI is contacting Wisconsin election officials. Here鈥檚 what we know.
The federal government鈥檚 probe into the 2020 election has reached Wisconsin, with several current and former election officials, including multiple people in Milwaukee, confirming they have been interviewed or approached by the FBI.
The exact nature of the investigation remains unclear, though it appears to be at least somewhat centered around the 2020 election. The agency鈥檚 election investigations elsewhere in the country have featured subpoenas for ballots and other election records, but legal experts still say it won鈥檛 be easy for the federal government to convince a court to give it access to ballots.
Milwaukee County officials are nonetheless preparing for that possibility, in part because they still retain ballots from the 2020 election, though they declined to discuss those preparations or comment on the record. Those ballots contain identifying information that could, in some cases, allow otherwise to be matched to the voters who cast them. Milwaukee is one of the few jurisdictions in Wisconsin that still has ballots from that election, and the city has target of voter-fraud accusations and related attacks from the political right.
Elsewhere in Wisconsin 鈥 in communities whose elections have faced less scrutiny and in the vast majority of municipalities where 2020 ballots were destroyed according to the standard retention schedules in state law 鈥 election officials are less alarmed and are instead focused on preparing for the midterm elections.
Still, news of the FBI interest has created confusion and some fear on the part of voters and election officials, reports.
What happened?
So far, the FBI has contacted multiple current and former election officials in Wisconsin.
The FBI interviewed Wisconsin Elections Commission deputy administrator Robert Kehoe sometime in late April or early May. The news of the interview was first reported by the . The interview focused on the 2020 election, with agents asking Kehoe to explain how Wisconsin elections operate.
The agency has also attempted to contact Milwaukee County Election Director Michelle Hawley. An agent left a business card at Hawley鈥檚 home when she was not there. Milwaukee County Clerk George Christensen criticized the agency for approaching Hawley at her home rather than through the county.
鈥淲hile we cooperate with all legitimate law enforcement actions, we will defend against any attack on our democracy and will defend the rights of voters of Milwaukee County,鈥 Christensen said in a statement.
Agents also left a card for, called, and texted a former Milwaukee election official, who confirmed the contact to Votebeat but requested anonymity because of personal safety concerns. That official declined to say whether they responded to the FBI.
Milwaukee the FBI has reached out to city employees about the probe.
鈥淭he president for whatever reason cannot seem to let it go that he lost an election,鈥 Johnson told a WISN 12 reporter.
Wisconsin Elections Commission spokeswoman Emilee Miklas declined to comment for this story. Other officials declined to speak on the record, and an FBI spokesperson didn鈥檛 answer Votebeat questions about the probe.
David Becker, the executive director of the nonpartisan nonprofit Center for Election Innovation and Research and a former Justice Department voting section attorney, said the federal government鈥檚 actions appeared more to be aimed at intimidating election officials than producing actionable criminal cases.
He pointed to FBI Director Kash Patel鈥檚 public statements in April suggesting , as well as federal officials discussing potential cases on social media before they鈥檙e brought before courts.
鈥淚f you think you鈥檙e going to bring charges and prosecute individuals, you don鈥檛 do anything that the federal government has done over the last few months,鈥 he said.
Becker also noted that any potential federal crimes connected to the 2020 election are 鈥渨ell beyond the statute of limitations for any potential federal jurisdiction or crimes,鈥 adding, 鈥淭his is a problem for any investigation relating to 2020.鈥
Even so, Becker said election officials鈥 worries were justified. He said the Election Official Legal Defense Network, which he leads, has received more requests for legal assistance from election officials than ever before 鈥渆ven though all of these efforts indicate that the federal government knows it鈥檚 got nothing.鈥
How do the events in Wisconsin relate to probes elsewhere?
It鈥檚 unclear how the FBI interviews in Wisconsin relate to the agency鈥檚 scrutiny of the 2020 election in other states.
In January, the FBI seeking records tied to the 2020 election. About a month later, related to the audit of the 2020 election in Maricopa County, Arizona, which includes Phoenix.
Separately, the to 2024 ballots in Wayne County, Michigan, home to Detroit.
Those jurisdictions share several characteristics with Milwaukee County. All are located in highly competitive swing states won by former President Joe Biden in 2020, and all became central targets of President Donald Trump, who repeatedly challenged the election results despite court rulings, audits, and reviews repeatedly reaffirming his loss.
Fulton, Wayne, Maricopa, and are the largest and most heavily scrutinized election jurisdictions in their respective states. Each has been the subject of persistent conspiracy theories about the 2020 election, many of which remain prevalent on social media, even after extensive investigations found no evidence of widespread fraud.
鈥淲hat鈥檚 really disconcerting,鈥 said former longtime Wisconsin election chief Kevin Kennedy, 鈥渋s the fact that there is a clear pattern here to try and continue to stir up issues that were resolved in every single opportunity there was to review them, whether it was a court case, an independent audit or the actual certification and review process that exists.鈥
What comes next?
The short answer is that nobody really knows.
Officials have been considering the possibility that the federal government may seize the city鈥檚 2020 ballots, which contain personally identifiable information.
Kennedy said recent actions by the Trump administration offer 鈥渘o reason to think that information that should be protected is going to be protected.鈥
Kennedy said Wisconsin鈥檚 decentralized election system was intentionally designed to distribute authority among local jurisdictions 鈥 both to keep election administration accountable at the community level and to limit the amount of sensitive voter information concentrated in any one place.
鈥淵ou put that at the national level,鈥 he said, 鈥渁nd it only takes one bad actor 鈥 and we鈥檝e got evidence there鈥檚 more than one of those already in the federal government 鈥 to totally disrupt the process when you consolidate that kind of information that鈥檚 protected through the various state and local laws and practices.鈥
Becker said it will be an uphill battle for the federal government to successfully obtain Milwaukee鈥檚 ballots. But he said the mere possibility that federal officials could theoretically identify how individual people voted is deeply troubling.
鈥淭hat is not the way a democratic society works,鈥 he said. 鈥淣ow, I don鈥檛 think they鈥檙e likely going to be able to do that. I think that鈥檚 going to be incredibly difficult. It鈥檚 not impossible, but the fact that they seem to engender this fear is troubling enough.鈥
was produced by and reviewed and distributed by 黑料社.